Throughout the duration of the novel, Mae became increasingly devoted to the culture at the Circle. Her transformation is almost frightening, quite honestly. In the beginning, it seems as though Mae plans to resist the insane culture of sharing that occurs at the Circle. For a while, she succeeds in keeping part of her life actually private. But unfortunately, as the novel progresses, Mae succumbs to policies of sharing that the Circle enforce. Mercer, the beacon of honesty and clarity in the novel, scolds Mae on her "new neediness" created by this social culture. This new neediness can be seen in Mae's behavior after the first Demoxie survey and in modern society.
In order to complete the Circle and achieve full transparency throughout the democratic sphere, citizens are given a true direct democracy. To exemplify this, the Circlers take part in a mandatory company-wide survey. While they're asked only very basic questions meant to demonstrate the efficacy of the system, the final question tears Mae apart. After four simple questions, Bailey jokingly asks the question "Is Mae Holland awesome or what?" To the vast majority of people, it would just be a fun little form of flattery. Mae is obviously extremely popular, what with being one of the first to go transparent and being somewhat of a celebrity within the Circle. But much to her dismay, only 97% of people said that she was awesome. How horrible, of the thousands of Circlers, a small fraction don't love Mae Holland! How shocking, that not everyone at the Circle finds Mae so awesome! The knowledge that three percent of her coworkers don't like her eats at Mae the rest of the day, and all that night. She frets over the small population that doesn't like her. Mae even goes as far to wonder how she can walk around campus the same way. Mae very clearly demonstrates the "new neediness" that Mercer acknowledged.
Much like Mae, adolescents in the modern age have become increasingly concerned with online validation, and equate that validation to self-worth. Too many teens have become obsessed with how many "likes" they get on Instagram. "Why did that specific person not like the picture? Was it intentional? I should have more likes; I have so many followers!" Far more often than should occur, adolescents allow this meaningless submission of validation to determine their feelings of self-with, even to impact their life in smaller ways. I've seen my friends make extra accounts, just to increase their likes. They've stressed, like Mae, over the people who didn't like their picture. "Did I make them mad? What's their problem? I thought we were friends!" Just because the little button on Instagram is a heart, doesn't mean that a like in any way equates to a level of emotion. People scroll through feeds quickly and randomly double tap. But too quickly, our society has turned social media into a cultural PartiRank. Popularity online somehow is believed to hold a real life equivalence. Behavior like Mae's is all too prevalent in today's society as well.
Mercer's notion of a "new neediness" is shown through Mae's behavior after the first Demoxie survey and in modern society. Sadly, our culture has moved to accept social media validation as a measure of personal value. We have allowed this social culture to override our sense of self, relaying on the "likes" of others to reassure our own value.
Thursday, October 13, 2016
Thursday, October 6, 2016
Who's drinking the Kool-Aid now?
From the beginning of the Circle, Annie was the golden girl. She was the perfect employee, she worked harder than anyone, and was incredible at ever task she took on. Annie was the reason Mae got a job at the Circle, the reason Mae's parents were on the Circle's health insurance plan, the reason Mae had a life she loved. Mae was even jealous of Annie's position in the company, her importance to everyone and her sometimes condescending attitude towards Mae. But as the story progressed, their relationship became much more strained, less of friendly and more professional. As Mae advances and becomes more important in the Circle, their relationship becomes more of a battle of loyalty to the company. However, it isn't until Mae's full transition to transparency that we can most clearly see the changes in Mae's and Annie's attitudes towards the Circle.
When Mae first started at the Circle, the constant sharing overwhelmed her. She offended a random coworker named Alistair when she didn't attend, or even acknowledge, an event in which he assumed she'd have an interest. She was even chastised for not allowing others to share in her kayaking hobby. Mae liked the privacy of kayaking, that she was disconnected from everything for a little while. She had no desire to share her experience, discuss it with other people.The necessity share everything at all times proved a bit strange to Mae, something she didn't feel wholly comfortable doing. Later in the novel, specifically on page 351, we see Annie display some of the same feelings towards this concept of sharing. Annie finally returns to the Circle after a long and trying trip to Europe, China, and Japan. Mae practically chases Annie down, trying to get a chance to talk with her old friend. Not only does Annie avoid Mae immediately upon her arrival, but even when Mae catches up with her, Annie is reluctant to share a whole lot. Granted, she couldn't share any of the classified information she's privileged to, but she even hastened the small talk she should've been eager to hold. Further, it isn't just Mae whom Annie's standoffishness affects; all of Mae's viewers feel it as well. Being in the Top 40 Gang, Annie should have been eager to share details of her trip with so many of the Circle's viewers. Yet, she couldn't have been more anxious to get away from Mae, to not be on camera anymore. It used to be Mae who wasn't overly willing to share so much with strangers, but as she became more comfortable with it, Annie seemed to shy away. Her reserved manner shows a shift in her commitment to the Circle and its goals.
Looking back again to Mae's initial attitude towards the Circle's policies, we can see her reservations to the whole "sharing is caring" idea. When Mae fails to post about her latest kayaking experience, she is chastised for being disinterested, for stealing the experience from others. Mae found the entire situation completely absurd. She didn't see how her escape from the world around her, her happy place, was a communal experience. It never dawned on her to basically "live tweet" her whole excursion. It was in this exchange that Mae felt burdened by the weight of the Circle's obligations, she felt her arm twisted to share everything she did. For a long time, Mae couldn't understand the Circle's involvement in almost every aspect of society. Although, towards the end of the story, Annie and Mae trade opinions on this, Annie becoming the skeptical one. Starting on page 392, at the Concept Kingdom Meeting, Annie speaks against the ideas of Bailey, Stenton, and Mae. The three had been leading the group in discussion of connecting Circle user accounts to voting registration. It was the goal to use the Circle to increase voting participation and awareness. Annie questions the Circle's authority, or at least necessity in this battle. Much like pre-transparency Mae, Annie doesn't see the need in extending the Circle's arm into the government. Her opposition draws disappointment from the two Wise Men present, and Mae shines as the Circle's "golden girl". This situation again exemplifies Annie's modified opinion of the Circle.
Throughout the course of the novel, we can clearly see that shift in Mae's and Annie's attitudes toward the Circle and it's goals. Though it was a gradual shift, it brought drastic changes to Mae and Annie's relationship. Their sort of "role reversal" within the company proved exceptionally straining on their friendship. Both Mae and Annie were consumed by the atmosphere at the Circle, but it didn't bode well for either of them.
When Mae first started at the Circle, the constant sharing overwhelmed her. She offended a random coworker named Alistair when she didn't attend, or even acknowledge, an event in which he assumed she'd have an interest. She was even chastised for not allowing others to share in her kayaking hobby. Mae liked the privacy of kayaking, that she was disconnected from everything for a little while. She had no desire to share her experience, discuss it with other people.The necessity share everything at all times proved a bit strange to Mae, something she didn't feel wholly comfortable doing. Later in the novel, specifically on page 351, we see Annie display some of the same feelings towards this concept of sharing. Annie finally returns to the Circle after a long and trying trip to Europe, China, and Japan. Mae practically chases Annie down, trying to get a chance to talk with her old friend. Not only does Annie avoid Mae immediately upon her arrival, but even when Mae catches up with her, Annie is reluctant to share a whole lot. Granted, she couldn't share any of the classified information she's privileged to, but she even hastened the small talk she should've been eager to hold. Further, it isn't just Mae whom Annie's standoffishness affects; all of Mae's viewers feel it as well. Being in the Top 40 Gang, Annie should have been eager to share details of her trip with so many of the Circle's viewers. Yet, she couldn't have been more anxious to get away from Mae, to not be on camera anymore. It used to be Mae who wasn't overly willing to share so much with strangers, but as she became more comfortable with it, Annie seemed to shy away. Her reserved manner shows a shift in her commitment to the Circle and its goals.
Looking back again to Mae's initial attitude towards the Circle's policies, we can see her reservations to the whole "sharing is caring" idea. When Mae fails to post about her latest kayaking experience, she is chastised for being disinterested, for stealing the experience from others. Mae found the entire situation completely absurd. She didn't see how her escape from the world around her, her happy place, was a communal experience. It never dawned on her to basically "live tweet" her whole excursion. It was in this exchange that Mae felt burdened by the weight of the Circle's obligations, she felt her arm twisted to share everything she did. For a long time, Mae couldn't understand the Circle's involvement in almost every aspect of society. Although, towards the end of the story, Annie and Mae trade opinions on this, Annie becoming the skeptical one. Starting on page 392, at the Concept Kingdom Meeting, Annie speaks against the ideas of Bailey, Stenton, and Mae. The three had been leading the group in discussion of connecting Circle user accounts to voting registration. It was the goal to use the Circle to increase voting participation and awareness. Annie questions the Circle's authority, or at least necessity in this battle. Much like pre-transparency Mae, Annie doesn't see the need in extending the Circle's arm into the government. Her opposition draws disappointment from the two Wise Men present, and Mae shines as the Circle's "golden girl". This situation again exemplifies Annie's modified opinion of the Circle.
Throughout the course of the novel, we can clearly see that shift in Mae's and Annie's attitudes toward the Circle and it's goals. Though it was a gradual shift, it brought drastic changes to Mae and Annie's relationship. Their sort of "role reversal" within the company proved exceptionally straining on their friendship. Both Mae and Annie were consumed by the atmosphere at the Circle, but it didn't bode well for either of them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)